Great podcast but their current “on the clock” shows where the host gives the guest options to choose from always ends up as basically just choose whoever you want. Offering them “best wr, best edge, best dtackle, or a wildcard of their choice” is lazy. Might as well just say pick who you want from everyone available for each pick.

I don’t understand how you guys continue to make Geno Smith out to be a lock top 10 Quarterback in the NFL! This is insane!

Please don’t have this annoying pretentious person on your otherwise regularly awesome show anymore.

Love this podcast but what is up with the sharp S’s? Is there no way to mix that out? I have to turn the volume up to hear Derek better but then when Mays chimes back in I have to turn it down because any word he says with an S is so sharp it hurts my head and my ears. Is it the microphone or the mixing of the audio? Would love if this could get fixed. Otherwise everything else is fantastic!

I understand we work for money but the amount of ads on this podcast are out of control. Dane needs to have his own podcast

Always very insightful and thoughtful analysis and do a good job covering the entire league as opposed to just a select group of teams

They were talking fax in this podcast. And it’s fun to listen to stuff you like.

I’ve been listening to this podcast for over two years now and I’ve learned so much about football. The hosts do a good job at balancing a philosophical and realistic approach to the sport.

My family and I thank you! I was compelled to complain about such foul language before so the least I can do is say thanks for the obvious successful attempts at not swearing so much and bleeping it out when you do. Always have loved the show, so thanks again! 5 stars from us!

I like robert and his knowledge but had stopped listening to the previous version of the show. When derrik joined , i was impressed by derrik. he and Robert are very enjoyable to listen to. Excellent show

Robert Mays is unbearable

Can you please add time stamps to your podcasts? Other shows that go long like you do it. I have stopped listening to your podcast because I only want to hear specific topics but it takes me forever to find them because you don’t put time stamps in the summary.

I was gonna write a review but first let’s take a quick break

Great podcast! I particularly enjoy it while on the plane as it helps me fall asleep without fail.

Increasingly convinced that Derrik is paid by Justin Herbert’s camp to do positive PR

Love the high level analysis! One of my few regular podcasts, and always fun. Don’t always agree with everything, but always makes me think.

The Nerd on Nerd talk gets a little dizzying, I love the classic dichotomy of the the Analytics Guy bantering with the “On the Field” Guy. One can give uniques insights that only data and intense film watching would yield while the other can pull it down to earth and talk about the physicality and reality of what the game entails.

This is not just one of my favorite football pods — but one of my favorite pods on any topic. Mays is one of the truly great hosts and football personalities out there. Knowledgable, curious, and zero smugness (a rarity in this field these days). I always learn a lot listening to this show. Keep up the great work, guys.

I feel like this show wants to be the place where football hipsters come to analyze football in new insightful ways. It also aims to be a place for smart conversations about the game and well-considered, constructive arguments. Thing is, I don’t find your analysis all that insightful. Listened to the first 20 minutes of “What we can learn from the final 4 teams episode” and the first two were “Don’t turn the ball over” and “Run the ball to add consistency to your offense”. Really? That’s what you learned? Should we add “Score more points than your opponent”? Additionally, you show bias quite a bit, which is fine because people are biased by nature, but in the same episode you just include the Lions because you want to. Is there something to be learned by the Commies beating them? I’m not sure, but why bend the rule there? All in all, I try this show out every couple months wanting it to be better but I get disappointed.

just fine. noticeably worse during the 2024-2025 season.

Enjoy the show and the personalities. Rarely keep up with the dissection of the plays but keeping up with the enthusiasm in the explanations is a breeze🙂 Can someone address the new colors on the logo this week? Something to do with playoffs? bye!

Love the show. As a high school OC and NFL junkie, the knowledge and insight on this pod makes it a must listen every week!(Miss Nate though) @Coach_Cohen1

Best part are the recaps after games and season previews dissecting each team division by division. I also love you guys talking about coaching carousel decisions. Want to make it better: get Mike Sando on midweek shows regularly. Yes, I miss him and Randy. Maybe pair him with Zak Keefer.

This show is joyful. The hosts are having a ball and it’s contagious. They love the NFL and relish talking about it. Breezy good vibes keep me coming back.

Robert and his former Mustache are my favorite podcast hosts. I miss Tice but Robert’s former Mustache is a near worthy substitute.

Robert is smart and insightful. Love his analysis and guests. One quibble is he can’t help himself from interrupting his guests, preventing them from finishing their thoughts. At times, he feels compelled to make a point that they are on the path of making. Overall, it’s one of the best league-wide football shows.

Had myself a good laugh when these two had their little herbert therapy session

The woman(?) who is the primary host should consider getting vocal coaching/therapy to correct their vocal fry.

I’ve been a pro football fan my whole adult life, but I’ve learned so much about the game this past season listening to Robert Mays and his guests. Not only that, but I was particularly moved by Robert talking having to put down his dog Molly on a recent episode.

Robert is a very interesting host with objective views which I’m a huge fan of. However, it’s very, very difficult to take a preview show seriously when the cohost mentions that he’s “manifesting” for a certain player times and as a result admits that it’s affecting his analysis. Very disappointing. Unbiased media is a thing of the past, unfortunately.

No other podcast blends Xs and Os technical knowledge of the game with genuinely fun and entertaining delivery.

The best and most informative football podcast out there

The show notes need detailed time stamps like Check the Mic podcast. I don’t have time to listen to everything and I don’t care about some of the content, like the New York teams.

I love this podcast. I am a more recent football fam and have learned so much from Robert. Plus he’s hilarious and I love his voice.

Robert: Your language level is semi-tough. When you & guests review games, it’s a first-person conversation. As in: Derek & I (not me). Lose “pretty good” & your swearing for adult attention.

Derek has really come into his own over the course of the season and he clearly knows his stuff, it’s been fun to see them grow as co hosts. Good balanced takes that are clearly well thought out. Planning on listening for a long time.

I love this podcast. Really know football. Filled me in on matchups and have great anaylisises

This is consistently the best football podcast. If you like in depth analysis, good questions and thoughtful answers, look no further. There are some exceptions but TV football shows are all about personalities, sound bites, and cliche-filled Q’ and A’s. Not this show. Opinions are backed up with data. I don’t always agree with Robert Mays but I understand his logic and views because they are always come with evidence. I understand the game better since I started listening to this show. Excellent work!

LOVE LOVE LOVE this show. Always giving good-natured, thoughtful football analysis. Been recommending it to friends. Robert and Derrik strike the perfect balance of personal and professional: I deeply appreciated when Robert shared with us what he was going through when he lost his furry family member, Molly and I’m so happy that other listeners seemed to appreciate it in the same way I did. Yet I am grateful that Robert and Derrik don’t spend too much time trying to force “funny” banter on us about every detail of what happened to them on their way to work each day. Miss me with that time-wasting mess. I also loved when they did what became a deep dive love letter to Lamar Jackson in a recent episode — seemingly just because. Beautiful. Loved the Money Down miniseries, too. More of those are welcome, whenever you find time. This show is one of my absolute favorites — no notes.

Nate is obviously missed, but Robert is still the man! I have no strong feelings either way about Derek yet. Definitely surprised to hear how incredulous they both were that a football fan might not care much about the MVP debate. Feels like a classic case of national pundits getting a tad out of touch with what matters to most fans. Not all of us like football purely for the arguments that may come with it - some of us just enjoy the game itself. That whole conversation really drove home for me just how much Nate brought to the show. Feels more narrative-driven now than before, but I’ll keep listening!

I’ve become a huge fan this year. Nice to hear real content and detail. A fun show. Happily subscribed

Miss the Nate and Robert superstar duo, but this is still such a great podcast for anybody who wants nuanced, thoughtful football content. It’s increasingly difficult to find and I appreciate you guys so much for it. Thank you. -Jodi

I listen to this year round and think it’s one of the best overall nfl shows. I listen multiple times a week

This show has the best combination of football stats and actual football analysis from people who know the game. It’s a great listen for anyone who loves football and wants to learn more about it.

I’ve loved listening to Mays since the Grantland days, and Klassen more than holds his own. The passion, the hard work, and the consistency shine through. Thanks for a great pod guys!

This has been my go to show for the past 2 years now. I miss Nate, (and love his show over at yahoo) but Derick has been great since taking over! I love the in depth analysis and deep dives into each game every week. Love listening to Robert rant about the bears every week (I’m a packers fan). Really love this show!

Real bad, unenjoyable, a lot of words and time spent to say very little of substance or consequence

Take a drink every time Mays says “right now” or “what this is going to look like” and you’ll end up in the hospital.

I can count on one hand the number of episodes that didn’t really interest me. I almost always find it a worthy listen!

Listen to it every weekend on my long run along the Chicago lakefront to prep me for the weekend’s slate of games. Love the energy and dedication that Robert and the rest of the crew bring.